A Central Coast Love/Hate Story With Justin Winery
Paso Robles locals have a love/hate relationship with Justin Vineyards & Winery. Some Paso locals swear at Justin while some locals swear by this vintner perched in the foothills west of Paso Robles.
Justin is a longtime member of this community, employing hundreds of people and donating freely to the community. Yet the winery’s gone through difficult patches with a divorce forcing a divestment, putting the winery in the hands of Wonderful Company. You may know them for their Halo Mandarins, Wonderful Pistachios and Fiji Bottled Water.
They clear cut a forest of oak trees in 2016 (Oak trees are a sacred cow in Paso Robles…as in Pass of the Oaks) but were caught and penalized by indignation of locals (the winery is located in the county of San Luis Obispo, not within the boundries and laws of Paso Robles city.) The Feds investigated Justin and Wonderful Company for sexual discrimination.
| Editor’s Note: In March of 2026 Wonderful Company‘s Justin Vineyards settled a sexual discrimination investigation by The Feds. Wonderful Company will pay $1.49 million to settle a sexual harassment lawsuit. The alleged harassment included, “recurring, frequent and offensive sex-based remarks, advances and unwelcome touching by supervisors” at its wineries. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission investigation started in 2022. The allegations date back to 2017. |
Their wine & customer service quality has had some ups and downs with changing personnel. The winery also instituted a tiered pricing program raising the price on all their wines. The entry level club shipment of 6 bottles will set you back $300+.
We are on our third iteration of membership and were ready to again quit for two reasons: 1) the pickup party cost $130 for attending and picking up our $300 wine club purchase (most winery pick up parties are complimentary.) 2) Every time we speak with a representative on the telephone, they act like you’ve interrupted them. They rarely even let you finish your sentence before giving you an answer. And the answer is usually ‘No’ we can’t do that. Irritating.
But at the moment, you can’t quarrel with their wine. It’s all good. So we decided to give them one last opportunity to keep us as customers.
We booked a tasting of four in their Estate Barrel Room for club members. Time for them to prove themselves with some quality customer service.
They saved the day with a gracious wine host and excellent wine. We’re still on board the wine club for now.
Robbie the wine host was attentive, accommodating and knowledgeable. He was also understaffed, working by himself juggling 6 groups of tasters spread throughout the barrel room. He shared a number of Justin’s Bordeaux style wines. Here we go:
Landmark Winery Pinot Grigio (a sister winery) $27 ✰+/✰-
2021 Rose (Syrah based) $20 ✰
2020 Right Angle (a smoky blend of Cabernet, Melbec, Petite Sirah & Petit Verdot) $50 ✰+
2019 Isosceles (Cabernet, Cabernet Franc & Merlot) $85 star ✰+
2019 Savant (an ‘Aussie’ style blend, Syrah & Cabernet Sauvignon) $55 ✰+/✰+ +
2017 Justification (Cabernet Franc & Merlot) $78 ✰+
2019 Reserve Cabernet (100% Cabernet) $65 ✰+
2017 Isosceles Reserve (Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc & Merlot) $720 for six bottles in a commemorative box ✰+ +
2015 Platinum Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon (heavy toast barrels & medium toast barrels blend) $175 ✰+ +
All these prices are retail. You can find Justification & Isosceles and some of their lower end Cabernet in retail stores. We’ve even seen some of their wines at Costco. But as you can see from the list above, these are not your usual $30 bottles of wine.
The wines are a cut above and Justin charges a premium for that taste. Tasting fee is $49. Make sure you have a full tank of gas when you run out to the estate (there is a tasting room downtown however for a shorter drive.) For you EV drivers there are two complimentary NCAS Type 2 chargers in their parking lot.
Some notes on our wine ranking system.
Bill & Erin Hodge write about California Wine, the estates & winemakers producing them and educational information about Vino. Living in California Wine Country provides a front row seat to the places you want to visit the most here in the Golden State.
– -✰ means -What’s next on your list of wines
-✰ means -Not liking it too much
✰ means -We’ll drink this wine, especially if it’s hosted!
✰+ means -You’ve got our attention and we might buy this wine.
✰+ + means -We’re hooked and we’re going to buy this wine.
When you see -✰/✰+ with a slash, it means we disagree.
My wife and I went to Justin Winery for a wine tasting and dinner tasting menu which lists on their website $225. per person. When the bill arrived it was $903.00 (DOUBLE THE PRICE THEY LISTED ON THEIR WEBSITE) We were in shock!!
When we got to Justin they tried to upsell us and I said, no thank you, I’d just like the $225. per person Dinner Tasting Menu we signed up for. The food was mediocre at best and they claim its a Michelin star restaurant. I’ve been to many amazing Michelin star restaurants and this was not on the same level, nor was it worth double what we were told when we made the reservation. I want to warn everyone going here, it’s not what they tell you.
My wife and I went to Daou winery just before visiting Justin, and Daou’s food and wine were much higher caliber and we were able to eat and try over 8 different wines for $150.00 for the both of us.